Batman suckin'...
Moderators: Daniel Jackson, greg
- Chiclo
- I'm Chiclo. My strong Dongs paid off well.
- Posts: 21990
- Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 1:09 am
- Favorite character: Kris
- Location: Texas
- Contact:
So I read the most recent issue of Batman and Robin today, the one Grant Morrison is writing. It introduces the next phase in the Batman decay - Batman Inc.
Grant Morrison has lifted the X-Corp idea from Grant Morrison's run on X-Men and thrown it into Batman. Grant Morrison should be offended at being so blatantly ripped off.
Grant Morrison has lifted the X-Corp idea from Grant Morrison's run on X-Men and thrown it into Batman. Grant Morrison should be offended at being so blatantly ripped off.
- Brother J
- Just trying to be self-deprecating
- Posts: 9789
- Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2004 5:05 pm
- Location: Cheese-Steak Land
Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'm very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.ian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.
- ian_house
- using a Welsh to American translator
- Posts: 5783
- Joined: Tue Apr 11, 2006 8:24 am
- Location: Vietnam
I love the bat-*SQUEE* crazy way that we have to be narrated to by a bear chested BatmanBrother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'm very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.ian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.

I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'm very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.ian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.
- xodacia81
- Here I am, happy as a clam
- Posts: 18404
- Joined: Sun Apr 22, 2007 10:09 pm
- Location: East of Chicago, West of New York
Morrison hasn't done anything even halfway decent since 52 and even his contributions there are debatable. I mean, the guy once had himself talking to Animal Man. Nothing he has written has made sense in ages, with Final Crisis being the finest example of craptacular I've yet seen from him. Can't speak to the artwork, as I've not picked up the series, but to hear that Neal Adams has lost it when it comes to The Bat, is sad.Knightt wrote:I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'm very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.ian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.
- Brother J
- Just trying to be self-deprecating
- Posts: 9789
- Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2004 5:05 pm
- Location: Cheese-Steak Land
I think the art in Batman: Odyssey would be passable, if Neal had only agreed to let someone else write it. The art actually reminds me of the stuff that was in the Continuity books, some of which was done by Neal, while other work was done by various Adams' clones. I don't know if this is Mr. Adams' first writing credit, but it's REALLY bad.xodacia81 wrote:Morrison hasn't done anything even halfway decent since 52 and even his contributions there are debatable. I mean, the guy once had himself talking to Animal Man. Nothing he has written has made sense in ages, with Final Crisis being the finest example of craptacular I've yet seen from him. Can't speak to the artwork, as I've not picked up the series, but to hear that Neal Adams has lost it when it comes to The Bat, is sad.Knightt wrote:I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'm very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.ian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.
- superman-prime
- scratch 1 for the coog guys
- Posts: 23252
- Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2007 3:27 am
- Location: phx az (east valley)
- dhudson1
- Rockin' out in Torquehalla
- Posts: 2050
- Joined: Fri Oct 16, 2009 10:08 pm
- Valiant fan since: 1991
- Favorite character: X-O
- Favorite title: duh, X-O
- Favorite writer: ditti
- Favorite artist: all of them
- Location: From Ohio, to Virginia, Illinois and back
I was wondering if anyone else had the same opinion of Morrison's work. It is hard to follow and doesn't make sense.xodacia81 wrote:Morrison hasn't done anything even halfway decent since 52 and even his contributions there are debatable. I mean, the guy once had himself talking to Animal Man. Nothing he has written has made sense in ages, with Final Crisis being the finest example of craptacular I've yet seen from him. Can't speak to the artwork, as I've not picked up the series, but to hear that Neal Adams has lost it when it comes to The Bat, is sad.Knightt wrote:I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'mian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.
very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.
- IanAlexavier
- Valiant. Back to basics.
- Posts: 6370
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2005 3:06 pm
- Location: SE Michigan, 21 bound books done.. many more to go...
- IanAlexavier
- Valiant. Back to basics.
- Posts: 6370
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2005 3:06 pm
- Location: SE Michigan, 21 bound books done.. many more to go...
dhudson1 wrote:If someone doesn't buy new ones, they will cease to exist.IanAlexavier wrote:![]()
You guys buy new comics??!?!![]()
![]()
I was picking up Justice League if it was marked down to $1 about a year ago. If you dont count that then its been about 4 years?? Whenever 52 started.
So, you are welcome!


- Cyberstrike
- Consider it mine!
- Posts: 5220
- Joined: Sat Oct 07, 2006 9:07 am
- Valiant fan since: Unity 1992
- Favorite character: Solar, Man of the Atom
- Favorite title: Unity
- Favorite writer: Jim Starlin
- Favorite artist: Jim Starlin
- Location: Indianapolis, Indiana
- Contact:
I've said several times on numberous message boards that Morrison is the most OVERRATED writer in comics other Batman: Arkham Asylem and JLA nothing that I've read from this guy writes makes any sense.dhudson1 wrote:I was wondering if anyone else had the same opinion of Morrison's work. It is hard to follow and doesn't make sense.xodacia81 wrote:Morrison hasn't done anything even halfway decent since 52 and even his contributions there are debatable. I mean, the guy once had himself talking to Animal Man. Nothing he has written has made sense in ages, with Final Crisis being the finest example of craptacular I've yet seen from him. Can't speak to the artwork, as I've not picked up the series, but to hear that Neal Adams has lost it when it comes to The Bat, is sad.Knightt wrote:I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'mian_house wrote:I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.Jersen wrote:I've actually really been digging the Morrison story, and Red Robin is another of my favorite DC books every month. Right now the only Marvel book I'm getting is Invincible Iron Man. I just don't have the funds or the gumption to keep up with the X-World and nothing else Marvel is doing has really caught my interest.
Batman Odyssey is absolutely horrible. So horrible, in fact, that I just have to follow it to the end to see how low it will go.
very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.
- Fatal Rose
- My posts can all fit in a short box
- Posts: 164
- Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 11:55 pm
- Location: Cali, USA
- Contact:
- xodacia81
- Here I am, happy as a clam
- Posts: 18404
- Joined: Sun Apr 22, 2007 10:09 pm
- Location: East of Chicago, West of New York
Agreed. A bad David Lynch film makes more sense than just about anything Morrison has EVER written.Cyberstrike wrote:I've said several times on numberous message boards that Morrison is the most OVERRATED writer in comics other Batman: Arkham Asylem and JLA nothing that I've read from this guy writes makes any sense.dhudson1 wrote:I was wondering if anyone else had the same opinion of Morrison's work. It is hard to follow and doesn't make sense.xodacia81 wrote:Morrison hasn't done anything even halfway decent since 52 and even his contributions there are debatable. I mean, the guy once had himself talking to Animal Man. Nothing he has written has made sense in ages, with Final Crisis being the finest example of craptacular I've yet seen from him. Can't speak to the artwork, as I've not picked up the series, but to hear that Neal Adams has lost it when it comes to The Bat, is sad.Knightt wrote:I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote:Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'mian_house wrote: I have for a while. But the last couple of months it's just lost me. Odyseey is mental... I'm enjoying how weird it is in a way.
very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.
- Brother J
- Just trying to be self-deprecating
- Posts: 9789
- Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2004 5:05 pm
- Location: Cheese-Steak Land
no such thing as a BAD David Lynch film, they are all works of a genius mind.xodacia81 wrote:Agreed. A bad David Lynch film makes more sense than just about anything Morrison has EVER written.Cyberstrike wrote:I've said several times on numberous message boards that Morrison is the most OVERRATED writer in comics other Batman: Arkham Asylem and JLA nothing that I've read from this guy writes makes any sense.dhudson1 wrote:I was wondering if anyone else had the same opinion of Morrison's work. It is hard to follow and doesn't make sense.xodacia81 wrote:Morrison hasn't done anything even halfway decent since 52 and even his contributions there are debatable. I mean, the guy once had himself talking to Animal Man. Nothing he has written has made sense in ages, with Final Crisis being the finest example of craptacular I've yet seen from him. Can't speak to the artwork, as I've not picked up the series, but to hear that Neal Adams has lost it when it comes to The Bat, is sad.Knightt wrote:I have to agree... I read up to issue four and was just disgusted. Crazy talk during the story (IF there is actually a 'story' being told), the art was NOT that great (and I am of the mind the Neal is THE Batman artist of my generation.... IMO) and there is no way I am going to continue with this book series. In fact, this is pretty much the series that prompted me to make this thread. There is not one Batman book out now that I am looking forward to reading. I will be trying Batman: The Dark Knight coming out later this month because of the Finch art and the focus on the supernatural but I am so scarred by what is going on now, I am afraid that even this new book will be like taking a cheese grater to my recent scars.Brother J wrote: Batman: Odyssey to me is unreadable, the dialogue just about makes no sense to me. The art is decent, but certainly not Adams at his best. I'm
very thankful that I only paid $1 each for this, instead of $3.99.

- ian_house
- using a Welsh to American translator
- Posts: 5783
- Joined: Tue Apr 11, 2006 8:24 am
- Location: Vietnam
Back on topic. Just read Batman & Robin 16 and The Return of Bruce Wayne 6. Batman & Robin was ace, really brought everything back together and made sense of everything for me and there was some serious action and 'hell yes' moments. But I'm sure it'll polarize fans with some of the revelations. The Return of Bruce Wayne didn't have quite the same bang for me and I didn't enjoy this series that much over all.
- Jersen
- Get those scissors away from my coupons
- Posts: 341
- Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 4:54 pm
- Location: Malvern, AR
I have to agree about Return #6, it had a bit of a lackluster ending for me, but perhaps it reads a little better if you read it in the context of reading the larger story at once and putting it between B&R #s 15 and 16.
One thing that really gave me a "hell yeah" moment was the ending portion of Red Robin #17. A nice moment where you see that no matter what, Tim IS Bruce Wayne's son, more than Damien will ever be. And then they go on patrol together, just like old times. It really brought up a possibility that I hadn't thought of. Just like Damien is Dick's partner for maintaining Gotham, Tim has already been working on an international scale, and can still be Bruce's partner!
One thing that really gave me a "hell yeah" moment was the ending portion of Red Robin #17. A nice moment where you see that no matter what, Tim IS Bruce Wayne's son, more than Damien will ever be. And then they go on patrol together, just like old times. It really brought up a possibility that I hadn't thought of. Just like Damien is Dick's partner for maintaining Gotham, Tim has already been working on an international scale, and can still be Bruce's partner!
- ian_house
- using a Welsh to American translator
- Posts: 5783
- Joined: Tue Apr 11, 2006 8:24 am
- Location: Vietnam
Agreed on both!Zool wrote:I've really enjoyed Batman & Robin, and if nothing else from this era 'sticks' Damian Wayne is a great addition to the mythos.
And I can confirm that the Greg Rucka/JH Williams Batwoman arc in Detective comics was superb (and the tpb is about as good looking a book as you could ever buy).
- Jersen
- Get those scissors away from my coupons
- Posts: 341
- Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 4:54 pm
- Location: Malvern, AR
Yeah, Detective was my favorite book every month while that story was going on. I loved the Question 2nd feature in there as well.Zool wrote:I've really enjoyed Batman & Robin, and if nothing else from this era 'sticks' Damian Wayne is a great addition to the mythos.
And I can confirm that the Greg Rucka/JH Williams Batwoman arc in Detective comics was superb (and the tpb is about as good looking a book as you could ever buy).